I know I'm something of a minor tech geek. Granted, I've never been much of an early adopter, and I've had limited funds for as long as I can remember, so I don't run out and buy everything that comes out. I just try to find out as much as I can about games, gadgets, and the like so that when I DO make a purchase, I can reasonably anticipate satisfaction.
But there is one thing that I simply do not care about, and it's the one thing that seems to be on everyone's mind these days. So, since the device is already ubiquitous, I felt the need to head it off in advance and say:
Frankly, my dear iPhone, I don't give a damn.
I'm already tired of hearing about it and the thing doesn't even come out until Friday.
PvP has been running a storyline involving resident Mac fanatic Brent's attempts to acquire one,
DiggNation's Mac zealot Kevin Rose has been talking about it a bunch, on his own show and on
TWiT in recent weeks (and it was also a top story on this week's TWiT even without Rose). It was even front-page news over on
Yahoo! who, in fairness, also presented an
anti-iPhone piece.
At the end of the day, however, it comes down to a few key things. First and foremost, there's no way in hell I'd EVER pay $500-$600 for a phone that doesn't perform sexual favors for me AT MY COMMAND. Look, I realize that it's meant to be an all-in-one device, replacing Smart Phones, iPod shuffles/Nanos, Palms/Blackberries, and what have you. I also realize that it's got a really neat interface and can do some fun tricks (huzzah, Google Maps!) But I just don't CARE. I don't NEED any of those features in my pocket, and certainly not at that price.
I could furnish a room at IKEA, or purchase a Wii with accessories and any number of games, for that price. That's three years of Netflix or WoW. That's an $11.50 NY Strip steak every week for a year. I could also get a decent phone free with the same two year contract, paying in the $40/mo range, and get almost a year's worth of service for the cost of JUST the iPhone (saying nothing of it's $58/mo plan).
For some, it's a matter of capacity: 4 or 8 GB isn't a lot. But that makes little difference to me. With Apple's intrusive DRM and the issues it can cause, I wouldn't feel secure trusting my music to a multitasking device where SO MUCH can go wrong, even if the thing held 80GB. It's annoying enough, I'm told, when your stand-alone iPod goes batty and needs to be reformatted (it DOES happen, despite the assurances of Mac fanciers). Add all of the potential issues associated with the new interface, the camera, phone/SIM card problems, and any of the myriad other things that can go wrong with a new piece of tech, and my confidence gets knocked back significantly. And I'm SURE that people at AT&T stores aren't going to know how to service the device yet, perhaps not even those at an Apple store. That means that, in all likelihood, any issues that come up will force you to send away your little all-in-one money pit and leave you with all-in-none for weeks.
And let's ask a frank question: how much of the iPhone's interface is made for function, how much for flash, and how much for that typical smug Mac cache? Seriously, does it matter if I have to navigate through menus or dial with buttons, or by tapping on a glass surface? Does it make much difference if I can turn my phone sideways to get a wider viewing area, or if I have to flip it open? I don't think either is terribly important. While I'll admit these features are COOL, I honestly don't think they go much deeper than that. At this stage, I'm not willing to spend a ton of cash simply on COOL. Apple's created an object of desire, but like most such objects, it's largely dependant on its aura and mystique, things which fade away a lot faster than the hole the money you spend on it will burn in your pocket.
Which is not to say that I think the phone won't work. I'm sure it will, even if there are bugs. I'm also sure that people will buy this thing like mad, and that most reviews will be positive. I'm sure plenty of people will be extremely happy with their iPhones, and they'll be a big convenience to those who use them to condense their array of gadgets into one slightly clunky thing. But how many of us are REALLY looking to do that? Not as many as those who want it just BECAUSE.
The fact is, however, that this device simply isn't designed for me. I carry a bag around, so I don't mind having more than one device in it. In fact, I'd PREFER to have a fully functional camera, fully functional mp3 player, and fully functional phone, rather than a half-assed version of each in one device that's cool looking. I'm not interested in being smug about my tech, and really never have been, so I'm lost on the bragging rights side, too. In the end, the iPhone is irrelevant to my lifestyle, and is also likely irrelevant to the lifestyle of MANY who WILL be seduced by it. I won't pretend that I wouldn't play around with it if a friend bought one. But that's all it is: a bunch of hype for a flashy toy, and I just can't be bothered with it all. This is the last you'll hear me talk about it.
Besides, I'd MUCH prefer an
rPhone. Wouldn't you?